Circular 230 duties — records, fees, conflicts and client errors

Part 3 · Lesson 2 · Practices and Procedures · about 30 min

In plain English

Circular 230 Subpart B is a checklist of duties. When a scenario feels like an ethics puzzle, find which numbered section it is — then apply that section's exact rule.

The story

EA Dana has a busy Tuesday:

  • 9:00 — A client who still owes her $900 asks for his original 1099s and bank statements back.
  • 11:00 — Preparing this year's return, she sees the client left a 1099-NEC off last year's return.
  • 2:00 — A married couple who are separating both want her to represent them, and one may claim innocent spouse relief against the other.
  • 4:00 — A client says, 'Just have the refund deposited to your account and take your fee out.'

Four scenes, four sections: §10.28, §10.21, §10.29 and §10.31.

Try it first 2 minutes · no peeking

For each scene above, write what Dana must do (or must not do). Then check yourself in the walk-through.

Jot your answer down, then scroll. Being wrong first is the point — it makes the walk-through stick.

Walk-through, step by step

The duty map — find the section first

Scene 2, step by step (§10.21)

  1. Dana must advise the client promptly about the omission. 2. She must explain the consequences of not correcting it. 3. She does not have to amend herself and does not have to tell the IRS. 4. If the client refuses to fix it, she may decide whether to keep the engagement — and she cannot repeat the error on a return she prepares (§10.34, §10.22).

Trap: 'Notify the IRS' is almost always wrong for §10.21. The duty runs to the client.

Practice questions

Answer on paper first, then tap Show answer & why. Want more? The practice set (22 questions).

Q1. A client owes EA Dana $900 and asks for his original 1099s and bank statements. What must she do?

  1. Keep them until the fee is paid
  2. Return copies only and keep the originals as security
  3. Return the original client records promptly, even though the fee is unpaid
  4. Send them to the IRS
Show answer & why

Answer: C — Return the original client records promptly, even though the fee is unpaid

The rule, in plain English

Client records must be returned on request despite a fee dispute (§10.28(a)), subject only to the narrow state-law retention exception.

How to decide

  1. Whose records? The client's originals.
  2. Fee dispute? Generally no excuse under §10.28(a) (state-law exception aside).
  3. Return them; you may keep copies.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. A fee dispute is not grounds to hold the client's own records.
  • B — Wrong. The client's originals must be returned; the practitioner may keep copies.
  • C — Correct. §10.28: a practitioner must, at the client's request, promptly return any and all records of the client needed to comply with federal tax obligations; a fee dispute does not change that (narrow exception: where state law lets a practitioner keep records in a fee dispute, only records that must be attached to the return must be returned).
  • D — Wrong. Records go back to the client, not the IRS.

IRS source

Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §10.28

Q2. While preparing a 2025 return, Dana learns her client omitted a 1099-NEC on his 2024 return (prepared by someone else). What does §10.21 require?

  1. Notify the IRS of the omission
  2. Amend the 2024 return without asking the client
  3. Withdraw immediately from all engagements
  4. Promptly advise the client of the omission and the consequences of not correcting it
Show answer & why

Answer: D — Promptly advise the client of the omission and the consequences of not correcting it

The rule, in plain English

§10.21: advise the client promptly of errors and consequences.

How to decide

  1. Locate the section: knowledge of client omission → §10.21.
  2. Duty: tell the client + consequences.
  3. Not required: tell IRS, amend.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. The duty runs to the client; no IRS notification is required.
  • B — Wrong. Only the client decides whether to amend.
  • C — Wrong. Withdrawal is not required by §10.21.
  • D — Correct. §10.21 requires advising the client of the noncompliance, error or omission and its consequences.

IRS source

Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §10.21

Q3. Spouses who are separating both ask Dana to represent them in an exam; one spouse may seek innocent spouse relief. If she reasonably believes she can represent both competently, what else does §10.29 require?

  1. Nothing more — competence alone is enough
  2. Each affected client gives informed consent, confirmed in writing, and she keeps the consents for 36 months after the representation ends
  3. Only the spouse seeking relief must consent orally
  4. OPR approval before starting
Show answer & why

Answer: B — Each affected client gives informed consent, confirmed in writing, and she keeps the consents for 36 months after the representation ends

The rule, in plain English

Conflict waiver: reasonable belief + not prohibited + informed consent confirmed in writing; keep 36 months.

How to decide

  1. Is there a conflict? Yes — directly adverse interests.
  2. Can she still act? Only if all §10.29(b) conditions met.
  3. Keep written consents 36 months.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Consent in writing is also required.
  • B — Correct. §10.29(b) allows representation with a conflict only with informed written consent; §10.29(c) requires keeping consents 36 months.
  • C — Wrong. Each affected client must consent, confirmed in writing.
  • D — Wrong. OPR does not pre-approve conflicts.

IRS source

Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §10.29

Q4. A client asks Dana to have his refund deposited to her business account so she can subtract her fee. Under §10.31 she may:

  1. Not do this — a practitioner may not endorse, negotiate or receive a client's refund into her account
  2. Do this if the client consents in writing
  3. Do this only for e-filed returns
  4. Do this if she refunds any excess within 30 days
Show answer & why

Answer: A — Not do this — a practitioner may not endorse, negotiate or receive a client's refund into her account

The rule, in plain English

Never take or negotiate a client's refund (§10.31).

How to decide

  1. Section: refund checks → §10.31.
  2. Any route of the refund through the practitioner → prohibited.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Correct. §10.31 bars endorsing or otherwise negotiating a refund check, and directing or accepting electronic refunds into an account the practitioner owns or controls.
  • B — Wrong. Consent does not lift the §10.31 prohibition.
  • C — Wrong. Electronic refunds into the practitioner's account are also barred.
  • D — Wrong. There is no excess-refund exception.

IRS source

Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §10.31

Q5. Which fee arrangement is not a permitted contingent fee under §10.27?

  1. A contingent fee for representing a client in an IRS examination of an original return
  2. A fee of 15% of the refund shown on an original return she prepares
  3. A contingent fee for a refund claim solely for statutory interest or penalties assessed by the IRS
  4. A contingent fee for services in a judicial proceeding under the Code
Show answer & why

Answer: B — A fee of 15% of the refund shown on an original return she prepares

The rule, in plain English

No contingent fee for preparing an original return; exceptions: IRS exam/challenge, timely claim after notice, interest/penalty claims, court cases.

How to decide

  1. Is the fee contingent? Yes.
  2. Is it on an original return? Yes → prohibited.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. This is a listed exception.
  • B — Correct. Contingent fees on original returns are prohibited; §10.27(b) lists only exam/challenge, certain claims, interest/penalty-only claims and judicial proceedings.
  • C — Wrong. This is a listed exception.
  • D — Wrong. This is a listed exception.

IRS source

Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §10.27(b)

Practice set (22 questions)

Same topic, more scenarios, each with the rule, how to decide, why every choice is right or wrong, and the IRS source.

Open the practice set (22 questions) →

Close the loop

Key rules in one line

§10.21 advise the client of errors; §10.28 return client records even if unpaid (narrow state-law exception); §10.29 written informed consent for conflicts; §10.31 never negotiate refund checks; §10.27 contingent fees only in listed cases.

Memory trigger: Find the section number first; the rule follows.
Sources checked
  • Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §§10.20–10.37
  • Pub. 947
  • Treas. Dept. Circular 230 (Rev. 6-2014)

Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Practice items are original, not real exam questions. Every rule names its source — check anything surprising there. Inflation-indexed penalty amounts are left out on purpose.