Before you ask what a person can do for a client, ask who they are: attorney, CPA and EA get unlimited practice; everyone else gets a narrow, listed slice.
The story
Dana's first week as an EA. Three people walk in on Monday:
Marco, a seasonal preparer with an AFSP Record of Completion, wants to know if he can go with his client to an Appeals conference on a return Marco prepared.
Dee is the full-time bookkeeper (an employee) of a small corporation and wants to talk to the revenue agent about the company's payroll return.
Sam, a new EA, asks how many CE hours he needs before his first renewal.
Each answer starts with the same question: what kind of person is this, under Circular 230?
Try it first 2 minutes · no peeking
Before reading on: can Marco (AFSP, unenrolled) represent his client at Appeals? Can Dee (full-time employee) represent her employer? Write yes/no and one reason each.
Jot your answer down, then scroll. Being wrong first is the point — it makes the walk-through stick.
Walk-through, step by step
Step 1 — Is it even 'practice'?
Practice before the IRS covers all matters connected with a presentation to the IRS about a client's rights or liabilities: preparing and filing documents, corresponding and communicating with the IRS, giving written advice with potential for avoidance, and representing at conferences and meetings (Circular 230 §10.2(a)(4)). But §10.8(b) lets any individual, for compensation, prepare a return, appear as a witness, or furnish information the IRS requests, and Loving v. IRS, 742 F.3d 1013 (D.C. Cir. 2014), held that preparing returns alone is not 'practice of representatives'. So for the SEE: preparing a return by itself is not practice; representing the client is (§10.8(b); Pub. 947).
Step 2 — Which bucket is the person in?
Attorney, CPA, enrolled agent (§10.3(a)–(c))Unlimited — any matter, any IRS office
Enrolled actuary / enrolled retirement plan agent (§10.3(d)–(e))Limited to their plan areas
AFSP Record of Completion holder (Rev. Proc. 2014-42; §10.7(c)(1)(viii))Only returns they prepared and signed; only exam, customer service, TAS — not Appeals or Collection
Unenrolled preparer with no AFSPNo representation (returns after 2015)
Special status under §10.7 (self, family, officer, partner, full-time employee, fiduciary)Only their own / their employer's / the entity's matter
Step 3 — Keep the credential
EAs renew every 3 years. Each enrollment cycle needs 72 CE hours, with at least 16 hours each year, 2 of them ethics — so at least 6 ethics hours per cycle (§10.6(e)(2)). A new EA's first cycle is prorated at 2 hours per month of the cycle. All paid preparers also need a current PTIN, renewed each year (§10.8; Treas. Reg. §1.6109-2).
Dropped-step trap: the exam loves AFSP people at Appeals or Collection. AFSP rights stop at examination, customer service and TAS — and only for returns the person prepared and signed.
Open the widget
Pick a person and an IRS office; the tool says whether they may represent and cites the rule.
Q1. Marco is an unenrolled preparer with a 2025 AFSP Record of Completion. He prepared and signed his client's 2025 return, which is now in Appeals. May Marco represent the client at the Appeals conference?
Yes, because he prepared and signed the return
No — AFSP holders may not represent before Appeals
Yes, if the client signs Form 8821
Yes, but only by phone
Show answer & why
Answer: B — No — AFSP holders may not represent before Appeals
The rule, in plain English
AFSP holders have limited representation: examination of returns they prepared and signed, customer service and TAS only.
How to decide
Classify Marco: unenrolled + AFSP.
Check the matter: a return he prepared and signed — OK so far.
Check the IRS office: Appeals is outside the AFSP list → No.
Why each choice is right or wrong
A — Wrong. Preparing and signing is required but it only opens exam, customer service and TAS — not Appeals.
B — Correct. AFSP representation is limited to revenue agents, customer service and TAS for returns they prepared and signed; Appeals and Collection are excluded.
C — Wrong. Form 8821 only lets someone receive information; it never grants representation.
D — Wrong. The limit is about the IRS function, not the method of contact.
IRS source
Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §10.3; Rev. Proc. 2014-42; Pub. 947, Practice Before the IRS and Power of Attorney
Q2. Dee is a full-time employee (bookkeeper) of Lakeview Inc. She is not a CPA, attorney or EA. May she represent Lakeview before a revenue agent on its payroll tax return?
No — only attorneys, CPAs and EAs can ever represent
Yes, but only if she prepared the return and holds an AFSP record
No — she may only receive transcripts with Form 8821
Yes — a regular full-time employee may represent the employer
Show answer & why
Answer: D — Yes — a regular full-time employee may represent the employer
The rule, in plain English
Limited practice without enrollment: individuals for themselves, family members, officers, partners, full-time employees, fiduciaries (§10.7).
How to decide
Is she a practitioner? No.
Does a §10.7 special status fit? Regular full-time employee of the taxpayer — yes.
Scope: only her employer's matters.
Why each choice is right or wrong
A — Wrong. §10.7 creates limited practice for listed people without enrollment.
B — Wrong. That is the AFSP rule; employee status is a separate, independent basis.
C — Wrong. Form 8821 is about information; she may actually represent under §10.7.
D — Correct. §10.7(c) lets a regular full-time employee represent the employer before the IRS.
IRS source
Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §10.7(c); Pub. 947, Practice Before the IRS and Power of Attorney
Q4. Which activity, by itself, is not practice before the IRS?
Representing a client at an examination conference
Corresponding with the IRS for a client about a proposed adjustment
Preparing a tax return and furnishing information the IRS requests
Filing a protest on a client's behalf
Show answer & why
Answer: C — Preparing a tax return and furnishing information the IRS requests
The rule, in plain English
Practice = all matters connected with a presentation to the IRS on a client's rights, privileges or liabilities; return prep alone is not.
How to decide
Ask: is someone presenting the client's case to the IRS?
Return prep / supplying facts / testifying → not practice.
Why each choice is right or wrong
A — Wrong. Conferences and meetings are core practice (§10.2(a)(4)).
B — Wrong. Communications with the IRS on a client's rights or liabilities are practice.
C — Correct. Under §10.8(b) (echoed in Pub. 947), any individual may for compensation prepare a return, appear as a witness, or furnish information at IRS request; Loving v. IRS (D.C. Cir. 2014) held return preparation alone is not practice. Representing, corresponding and filing protests for a client are practice.
D — Wrong. Preparing and filing documents with the IRS for a client is practice.
IRS source
Circular 230 (31 CFR Part 10) §10.8(b), §10.2(a)(4); Pub. 947, Practice Before the IRS and Power of Attorney; Loving v. IRS, 742 F.3d 1013 (D.C. Cir. 2014)
Attorneys, CPAs and EAs have unlimited practice; AFSP holders only examination/customer service/TAS for returns they prepared and signed; §10.7 lets self, family, officers, partners, full-time employees and fiduciaries act in their own limited matters; EAs need 72 CE hours per 3-year cycle (16/yr, 2 ethics).
Memory trigger: ACE are unlimited (Attorney, CPA, EA); everyone else gets a slice.
Pub. 947, Practice Before the IRS and Power of Attorney
IRS Enrolled Agent FAQ (irs.gov)
Rev. Proc. 2014-42 (Annual Filing Season Program)
Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Practice items are original, not real exam questions. Every rule names its source — check anything surprising there. Inflation-indexed penalty amounts are left out on purpose.