Today's idea
Three small rules cause a lot of wrong answers: meals are 50%, the simplified home office stops at 300 sq ft × $5, and the QBI wage/UBIA limit only bites once taxable income is high. Then employment tax: decide employee or contractor by the facts, and know who pays which half of FICA.
The story
Priya Raman runs a one-woman photography and brand-consulting studio as a sole proprietor (Schedule C). She works from a spare room.
Expenses. She spent $4,000 taking clients to lunch and dinner (she was there and the meals were not lavish). Her home is 2,000 sq ft and the office is 200 sq ft. Home costs were $24,000 for the year, and office-related depreciation is $800.
QBI. Her qualified business income is $200,000. The studio paid $40,000 of W-2 wages to an assistant and owns equipment with an unadjusted basis (UBIA) of $100,000. Her taxable income before the QBI deduction is $300,000 (single).
Employment tax. She hires a second-shooter who sets her own schedule, uses her own cameras and works for other studios. Later Priya wonders about moving her studio into an S corporation: profit is $150,000, market pay for her services is $90,000, but she'd pay herself only $20,000 and take $100,000 as distributions.
Walk-through
Step 1 — Meals and the home office
Business meals are generally 50% deductible — $4,000 becomes $2,000 — when you (or an employee) are present and the meal isn't lavish. Entertainment (tickets, golf, sporting events) is nondeductible; if food at an event is separately stated on the invoice, the food can still be the 50% meal (Pub 463).
Home office needs a space used regularly and exclusively for the business (and it must be the principal place of business or otherwise qualify). Two methods, you pick one for the year: simplified = $5 × business square feet, up to 300 sq ft (max $1,500); regular = the business-use percentage of actual home costs plus depreciation on the office.
- Business-use percentage (200 ÷ 2,000)10%
- Regular method: 10% × $24,000 + $800 depreciation$3,200
- Simplified method: $5 × 200 sq ft$1,000
- Larger choice this year (regular)$3,200
Both methods are limited by the gross income from the business use of the home (income minus other business expenses that aren't home-related). Regular-method depreciation comes last in the ordering. A 400 sq ft office under the simplified method still gets only $1,500.
Step 2 — The QBI deduction (§199A)
Sole proprietors and pass-through owners may deduct up to 20% of qualified business income (not from a C corporation, and not wages you earn as an employee). The deduction is also capped by 20% of taxable income less net capital gain. The wage/UBIA limit applies only above a taxable-income threshold: for 2025, $197,300 (single) / $394,600 (joint). At or below it, you use the simple Form 8995 and the deduction is just 20% of QBI. Above the top of the phase-in ($247,300 / $494,600) the limit applies in full; in between it phases in (Form 8995-A).
- 20% of QBI ($200,000)$40,000
- Limit A: 50% × $40,000 W-2 wages$20,000
- Limit B: 25% × $40,000 + 2.5% × $100,000 UBIA$12,500
- Limit = the greater of A and B$20,000
- Deduction = lesser of 20% of QBI and the limit$20,000
SSTBs. A specified service trade or business (health, law, accounting, consulting, athletics, financial services, performing arts and similar) counts as a qualified trade or business at or below the threshold, is phased out in the range, and gets no QBI deduction above it. A photography studio isn't automatically an SSTB; a consulting practice can be. The widget doesn't model SSTBs.
Step 3 — Employment tax: who is an employee, and who pays what
Employee or independent contractor is decided on the common-law facts in three groups: behavioral control (instructions, training), financial control (who supplies tools, who bears unreimbursed expenses, chance of profit or loss), and the relationship (written contract, benefits, permanency, whether the work is key to the business). No single fact decides it. Priya's second-shooter — own schedule, own cameras, several clients — leans independent contractor: Priya issues her a Form 1099-NEC if she pays $600 or more (for 2025 payments). Get it wrong and Priya can owe the employment taxes for that worker.
FICA (2025): Social Security 6.2% each for employer and employee on wages up to $176,100; Medicare 1.45% each on all wages; plus 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax on the employee only on wages over $200,000. On $250,000 of wages the employer owes $10,918 + $3,625 = $14,543; the employee owes that plus $450 = $14,993. FUTA is 6.0% on the first $7,000 of each employee's wages, reduced by a credit to an effective 0.6% if state unemployment tax is paid on time.
A sole proprietor pays self-employment tax as both halves: 15.3% on 92.35% of net earnings (12.4% Social Security up to the same wage base, 2.9% Medicare), and deducts half of it. On $100,000 of profit: $14,130 of SE tax, $7,065 deductible. You file Schedule SE if net earnings are $400 or more.
Deposits: monthly if the lookback-period total was $50,000 or less, semiweekly if more, and next-day once a liability hits $100,000.
Step 4 — S-corporation owners and payroll
An S-corporation shareholder who works in the business is an employee and must be paid reasonable compensation as W-2 wages before taking distributions. Distributions aren't subject to FICA, so the temptation is a tiny salary. Priya's plan — $20,000 of wages against $90,000 market pay (22%) with $100,000 distributed — is the classic red flag; the IRS can recharacterize distributions as wages. The Form 1120-S instructions say distributions and other payments to an officer are treated as wages to the extent they're reasonable compensation. Lesson 12 returns to S-corporation rules.
Credits. The widget has no credits section and I haven't drilled credits beyond one verified fact: the research credit is figured on Form 6765, and non-pass-through filers claim business credits on Form 3800 (partnerships and S corporations file Form 6765 themselves). Treat other credits as unstudied here — see the sources note.
Practice questions
Answer all of them on paper first. Then tap Show answer & why: the rule, how to decide, why each choice is right or wrong, the numbers, and the IRS source. Want more? The practice set (20 questions) has more scenarios on this topic.
Q1. Priya spends $4,000 taking clients to business meals (she is present, nothing lavish). How much can she deduct?
- $4,000
- $0
- $2,000
- $1,000
Show answer & why
Answer: C — $2,000
The rule, in plain English
Business meals are generally 50% deductible (taxpayer present, not lavish).
How to decide
- Meal with a business purpose? → 50%.
- Entertainment → $0.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. 100% is the classic trap; the general rule is 50%.
- B — Wrong. Entertainment is nondeductible, but business meals are still 50% deductible.
- C — Correct. Business meals are generally 50% deductible.
- D — Wrong. 25% isn't a rule for meals.
IRS source
Pub 463 (2025).
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Q2. Priya's home office is 400 sq ft in a 2,000 sq ft home. Using the simplified method, what is the most she can deduct (assuming enough business income)?
- $1,500
- $2,000
- $1,000
- $4,800
Show answer & why
Answer: A — $1,500
The rule, in plain English
Simplified home-office method: $5 per square foot, up to 300 square feet ($1,500 maximum).
How to decide
- Office sq ft, capped at 300.
- × $5.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Correct. $5 × 300 sq ft maximum = $1,500.
- B — Wrong. $5 × 400 ignores the 300 sq ft cap.
- C — Wrong. That's $5 × 200 sq ft — her actual office for the main example, not this question.
- D — Wrong. That's 20% of $24,000 of home costs — the regular method's percentage, and this question gives no home costs.
IRS source
Pub 587 (2025), simplified method.
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Q3. Priya (single) has QBI of $200,000, taxable income before QBI of $300,000, W-2 wages of $40,000 and UBIA of $100,000. What is her QBI deduction (ignoring the overall taxable-income cap)?
- $40,000
- $12,500
- $50,000
- $20,000
Show answer & why
Answer: D — $20,000
The rule, in plain English
Above the threshold range, QBI deduction = lesser of 20% of QBI or the greater of 50% of W-2 wages or 25% of wages + 2.5% of UBIA.
How to decide
- 20% × QBI.
- Wage/UBIA limit = greater of 50% × wages or 25% × wages + 2.5% × UBIA.
- Deduction = lesser of the two.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. That's the raw 20%; above $247,300 of taxable income the wage/UBIA limit applies.
- B — Wrong. That's the smaller limit leg; the limit uses the greater of the two.
- C — Wrong. Limit legs mix up: 50% of wages is $20,000, not $50,000.
- D — Correct. 20% of QBI is $40,000; the limit is the greater of $20,000 (50% of wages) and $12,500 (25% of wages + 2.5% of UBIA), so $20,000. Deduction = lesser = $20,000.
IRS source
Form 8995-A instructions (2025).
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Q4. An employer pays one employee $250,000 of wages in 2025 (Social Security wage base $176,100). What is the employer's FICA?
- $14,993
- $14,543
- $19,125
- $14,130
Show answer & why
Answer: B — $14,543
The rule, in plain English
Employer FICA: 6.2% Social Security up to the $176,100 wage base plus 1.45% Medicare on all wages. Additional Medicare Tax is employee-only.
How to decide
- 6.2% × min(wages, $176,100).
- 1.45% × all wages.
- Add; no employer 0.9%.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. That includes the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax, which the employer doesn't owe.
- B — Correct. 6.2% × $176,100 = $10,918 plus 1.45% × $250,000 = $3,625. The 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax is the employee's only.
- C — Wrong. 7.65% on all $250,000 ignores the Social Security wage base.
- D — Wrong. That's the self-employment tax on $100,000 — a different worker.
IRS source
Pub 15 (2025).
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Q5. Priya engages a photographer who sets her own hours and methods, uses her own equipment, bears her own expenses and works for other studios. What is the most likely treatment, and what does Priya file?
- Employee; Priya withholds and issues a Form W-2
- Employee, because she performs a service Priya needs
- Independent contractor; Priya issues a Form 1099-NEC if she pays $600 or more
- Independent contractor; no information return because she isn't paid through payroll
Show answer & why
Answer: C — Independent contractor; Priya issues a Form 1099-NEC if she pays $600 or more
The rule, in plain English
Worker status turns on behavioral control, financial control and the relationship; contractors paid $600+ get Form 1099-NEC.
How to decide
- Who controls how the work is done? Who bears expenses and profit/loss? Does the worker serve others?
- Contractor → Form 1099-NEC if paid $600 or more.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. The behavioral, financial and relationship facts point the other way.
- B — Wrong. One factor (being key to the business) doesn't decide it; the cluster does.
- C — Correct. The facts in all three groups point to an independent contractor, who pays her own self-employment tax.
- D — Wrong. Payments of $600 or more of nonemployee compensation require Form 1099-NEC.
IRS source
Pub 15-A; Form 1099-NEC instructions.
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Numbers follow tax year 2025 (the Nov 2026 SEE tests 2025 law per the Candidate Information Bulletin).