Today's idea
An S election fails on who owns it or how many kinds of stock it has, not on how profitable it is. A partnership's guaranteed payment comes off the top before the profit share is figured — and partners can lose deductions to the at-risk rule.
The story
Part 1 — the S corporation. Jon and Mara Kessler (spouses) and Jon's brother Eli own Kessler Millwork, Inc., a domestic corporation that wants to be an S corporation. A friend suggests letting the Kessler Family Partnership buy some shares, and suggests giving Eli preferred dividend rights so he's paid first. Later, one shareholder, Rita, sells her shares to a nonresident alien cousin.
Part 2 — the partnership. Dana and Lee share profits 50/50 in a design partnership. Dana is guaranteed $40,000 a year for managing the office. Ordinary income before that payment is $120,000. In a slow year it is only $30,000.
Part 3 — at risk. Sam is a partner in a different partnership. He contributed $20,000 cash, is personally liable for $10,000 of its debt, and shares $30,000 of nonrecourse financing that isn't secured by other property. His share of the year's loss is $45,000.
Walk-through
Step 1 — S-corporation eligibility
Form 2553's 'who may elect' tests: a domestic corporation (or eligible domestic entity); no more than 100 shareholders (a spouse counts with the individual, and all members of a family can be treated as one shareholder); shareholders only individuals, estates, certain trusts, and certain exempt organizations (401(a) and 501(c)(3)); no nonresident alien shareholders; one class of stock; and not an ineligible corporation (certain banks using the reserve method, insurance companies, DISCs). The corporation needs a permitted tax year; December 31 is the simple one.
Apply them: the Kessler Family Partnership as a shareholder → not allowed (partnerships can't own S-corporation stock). Preferred dividend rights for Eli → a second class of stock (the test is whether all shares have identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds; voting differences are ignored). The nonresident alien cousin → the S election is lost (a termination; the exact effective date of termination wasn't verified in these sources). Jon, Mara and Eli themselves count as one family for the 100 limit.
Trusts. Only certain trusts can own S stock — a qualified subchapter S trust (QSST) or electing small business trust (ESBT) with the proper election, plus grantor trusts and similar. Learn the names; the exam wants to know they're possible, with an election.
Step 2 — Reasonable compensation and S-corporation fringe benefits
A shareholder who works in the business is an employee. The Form 1120-S instructions say distributions and other payments to an officer are treated as wages to the extent they're reasonable compensation for services. The IRS can also adjust items when a family member renders services or furnishes capital without reasonable compensation. So: pay a market wage first (with payroll tax), distributions after. (Lesson 11 has the widget for this.)
More-than-2% shareholders (owning more than 2% of the stock or voting power on any day of the year, using attribution rules) get special treatment: fringe benefits paid for them are included in their Form W-2 box 1 wages, and their health insurance premiums are reported in box 14 of the W-2 and may be deductible on Schedule 1, line 17.
Step 3 — Partnership operations: guaranteed payments
A guaranteed payment is a payment to a partner for services or use of capital determined without regard to partnership income. The partnership deducts it (Form 1065, line 10) and reports it on Schedules K and K-1. The partner reports it as ordinary income (Schedule E) in the partner's tax year in which the partnership's year ends. Order: take the guaranteed payment off first, then apply the profit percentage to what's left.
- Ordinary income before the payment$120,000
- − Dana's guaranteed payment−$40,000
- Residual ordinary income$80,000
- Dana's 50% share of the residual$40,000
- Plus her guaranteed payment$40,000
- Dana's total ordinary income from the partnership$80,000
In the slow year, the partnership has only $30,000 before the payment. The payment still comes off: residual = −$10,000, Dana's share of the loss = −$5,000, and Dana still reports the full $40,000 of guaranteed payment as ordinary income, netting to $35,000 (Pub 541: the partner reports the full guaranteed payments and separately takes her share of the loss, subject to the loss limits). Also: guaranteed payments generally count for the partner's self-employment tax, and partnership-paid health insurance for a partner is treated as a guaranteed payment.
Step 4 — The at-risk limit
After basis, the next cap on a partner's (or S-corporation shareholder's) deductible loss is the at-risk amount (Form 6198), and only then the passive activity limit (Form 8582). You're at risk for cash you contributed, the adjusted basis of property you contributed, and debt you're personally liable for (or debt secured by other property, to the extent of its net fair market value). You are not at risk for nonrecourse debt (except qualified nonrecourse financing secured by real property used in holding real property), or amounts protected by guarantees, stop-loss agreements or insurance-like arrangements.
- Basis: $20,000 cash + $10,000 recourse + $30,000 nonrecourse debt share$60,000
- At risk: $20,000 cash + $10,000 recourse debt$30,000
- Loss allowed (lesser of basis, at risk, and the $45,000 loss)$30,000
- Suspended loss carried forward$15,000
Next year Sam contributes another $8,000 of cash. His at-risk amount rises by $8,000, so $8,000 of the suspended loss is released (ignoring passive rules) and $7,000 stays suspended. Recapture: if the at-risk amount falls below zero (for example, a distribution pushes it to −$5,000), you add to your income the lesser of the negative amount and the losses previously deducted — here $5,000.
Order of limits: basis → at-risk → passive → (for individuals) the excess business loss limit on Form 461. A loss must clear each gate in order.
Practice questions
Answer all of them on paper first. Then tap Show answer & why: the rule, how to decide, why each choice is right or wrong, the numbers, and the IRS source. Want more? The practice set (22 questions) has more scenarios on this topic.
Q1. Kessler Millwork, Inc. wants to elect S status. Which would prevent the election?
- Jon and Mara, spouses, each own shares
- A partnership owns some of the stock
- Some shares are voting and some are nonvoting with identical distribution and liquidation rights
- The corporation has 40 individual shareholders
Show answer & why
Answer: B — A partnership owns some of the stock
The rule, in plain English
S corp shareholders must be individuals, estates, certain trusts or certain exempt organizations; partnerships can't be shareholders.
How to decide
- Check each shareholder type.
- Then count (100, family rule) and one class of stock.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. A spouse is counted with the individual for the 100-shareholder limit, and both are individuals anyway.
- B — Correct. A partnership isn't a permitted shareholder.
- C — Wrong. Voting differences are disregarded; one class remains.
- D — Wrong. 40 is well under the limit of 100.
IRS source
Form 2553 instructions (2025).
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Q2. Eli is given the right to a $5 per share dividend before any other shareholder is paid. What is the effect on the S election?
- A second class of stock exists, so S status is lost
- None, because the shares are all common stock
- None, as long as Eli votes the same as the others
- The election is fine, but Eli is treated as a creditor
Show answer & why
Answer: A — A second class of stock exists, so S status is lost
The rule, in plain English
An S corp may have only one class of stock: identical distribution and liquidation rights (voting differences are allowed).
How to decide
- Do any shares get different distribution or liquidation rights?
- Yes → second class of stock → S status lost.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Correct. All shares must have identical rights to distribution and liquidation proceeds.
- B — Wrong. The label doesn't matter; identical distribution rights do.
- C — Wrong. Voting is the one difference that's allowed, but this is a distribution difference.
- D — Wrong. Nothing in the S rules converts the stock to debt here.
IRS source
Form 2553 instructions (2025), one class of stock.
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Q3. Dana's partnership has $120,000 of ordinary income before a $40,000 guaranteed payment to her. She has a 50% profits share. What total ordinary income does Dana report?
- $60,000
- $40,000
- $100,000
- $80,000
Show answer & why
Answer: D — $80,000
The rule, in plain English
A partner reports the guaranteed payment plus their share of the income left after deducting it.
How to decide
- Ordinary income − guaranteed payment = residual.
- Partner's % × residual + guaranteed payment.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. That's 50% of $120,000; the guaranteed payment is separate and comes off first.
- B — Wrong. That's her share of the residual only; she also reports the guaranteed payment.
- C — Wrong. Applies 50% to the payment and double counts.
- D — Correct. $120,000 − $40,000 = $80,000 residual; 50% = $40,000, plus the $40,000 guaranteed payment.
IRS source
Pub 541, Guaranteed Payments.
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Q4. Sam contributed $20,000 cash, is personally liable for $10,000 of partnership debt and shares $30,000 of nonrecourse debt not secured by other property. His share of the loss is $45,000. Ignoring passive rules, how much can he deduct?
- $45,000
- $20,000
- $30,000
- $60,000
Show answer & why
Answer: C — $30,000
The rule, in plain English
At-risk amount = cash and property contributed + recourse debt (+ qualified nonrecourse real estate financing); ordinary nonrecourse debt raises basis but not at-risk.
How to decide
- Basis limit first.
- At-risk = cash + recourse debt (exclude ordinary nonrecourse).
- Loss allowed = smaller; rest suspended.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. Basis allows it, but at-risk doesn't; the nonrecourse debt isn't at risk here.
- B — Wrong. Cash only; personal liability for the $10,000 of debt also counts as at risk.
- C — Correct. Basis is $60,000, but the at-risk amount is only $30,000 (cash plus recourse debt). The other $15,000 is suspended.
- D — Wrong. Limits the deduction to basis, but the loss is $45,000 and the at-risk amount is the binding cap.
IRS source
Pub 925, At-Risk Limits; Form 6198 instructions.
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Q5. In what order are a partner's loss limits applied?
- Passive activity, then at-risk, then basis
- Basis, then at-risk, then passive activity
- At-risk, then basis, then passive activity
- All three at once, using the smallest
Show answer & why
Answer: B — Basis, then at-risk, then passive activity
The rule, in plain English
Loss limits apply in order: basis, then at-risk, then passive activity (then excess business loss for individuals).
How to decide
- Basis → at-risk → passive, each on what the previous allowed.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. That's backwards: basis comes first.
- B — Correct. Each limit applies in order to whatever the previous one allowed; individuals then face the excess business loss limit.
- C — Wrong. Basis comes before at-risk.
- D — Wrong. They're applied in a sequence, and suspended amounts follow each rule separately.
IRS source
Form 1065 Schedule K-1 instructions; Pub 925.
Re-read the walk-through Open the widget Missed it? Add to my notes
Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Numbers follow tax year 2025 (the Nov 2026 SEE tests 2025 law per the Candidate Information Bulletin).