Kestrel Design goes corporate: §351, dividends, and choosing the entity

Lesson 10 · Business Entities and Considerations · about 55 min · tax year 2025

Today's idea

Moving a business into a corporation can be tax-free (§351) if the people who put property in end up with 80% control — but boot is taxed. A C corporation pays 21% and its shareholders pay again on dividends (to the extent of E&P). An S corporation or partnership avoids the second layer, which is why entity choice is a trade-off, not a rule.

The story

Ben Adeyemi and Carla Moreno run Kestrel Design as a sole proprietorship/partnership of sorts, and are deciding how to set up for growth.

Step 1 — Incorporating. Ben will transfer equipment with an adjusted basis of $40,000 and a value of $100,000 to a new corporation, Kestrel Design, Inc., for stock, plus he takes $10,000 of cash out as part of the deal. Ben and Carla together will own 100% of the stock right after.

Step 2 — Distributions. Later, as a C corporation, Kestrel pays Ben $50,000 in cash. Kestrel has $30,000 of earnings and profits (E&P). Ben's stock basis is $25,000. In a bigger year Kestrel pays $80,000 instead.

Step 3 — The choice. Before incorporating, Ben asks whether Kestrel should be a C corporation, an S corporation, or stay a partnership/sole proprietorship. A reasonable profit number is $200,000 a year, with $80,000 of it paid to Ben as salary.

Try it first 2 minutes · no peeking

Before reading: (1) In Step 1, how much gain does Ben recognize when he incorporates, and what is his basis in the stock? (2) In Step 2, how much of the $50,000 is taxed as a dividend? (3) In Step 3, which structure do you guess has the lowest tax at $200,000 — and does your answer change if the C corporation keeps its profits instead of paying dividends?

Hint: write down what "E&P" stands for and what it does to a distribution.

Jot your answer down, then scroll. Being wrong first is the point — it makes the walk-through stick.

Walk-through

Step 1 — §351: moving property into a corporation

Normally, swapping property for stock would be a sale: gain $100,000 − $40,000 = $60,000. But if the transferors (as a group) own at least 80% of the voting power and 80% of each other class of stock immediately after the exchange, §351 says no gain or loss is recognized. Boot (cash or other property, not stock) is the exception: gain is recognized up to the boot. So Ben recognizes $10,000 and defers $50,000.

Stock basis = adjusted basis of what he gave − boot received + gain recognized = $40,000 − $10,000 + $10,000 = $40,000. (The corporation's basis in the equipment is generally his basis plus the gain he recognized: $50,000.) If the control test failed (say transferors got only 70%), the whole $60,000 would be taxed and his stock basis would be $90,000 — the value less the cash.

Loss rule. If you own more than 50% of the corporation's stock, you can't deduct a loss on a related-party exchange (Pub 542 refers to Pub 544).

Step 2 — C-corporation distributions: E&P decides

A C corporation pays tax at a flat 21% and gets no deduction for dividends. When it pays a distribution, the shareholder treats it in this order: (1) dividend to the extent of the corporation's earnings and profits (E&P); (2) tax-free return of capital that reduces the shareholder's stock basis; (3) capital gain once basis is gone.

In the bigger year ($80,000): dividend $30,000, return of capital $25,000 (all of his basis), and $25,000 of capital gain. The corporation reports nondividend distributions on Form 5452 and issues Form 1099-DIV for dividends.

Some C-corporation rules that show up: the return is Form 1120, due the 15th day of the 4th month after year end (April 15 for calendar year); charitable contributions are limited to 10% of taxable income (computed before certain items); NOLs offset only 80% of taxable income for NOLs arising after 2017; and a corporation gets a dividends-received deduction for dividends from other corporations (50%, 65% or 100% depending on ownership).

Step 3 — Choosing the entity

Defaults: a sole owner with no LLC is a sole proprietor (Schedule C); a single-member LLC is disregarded; a multi-member LLC is a partnership (Form 1065); a state-law corporation is a C corporation (Form 1120). Elections: Form 8832 to be taxed as a corporation; Form 2553 to be an S corporation (an eligible entity that files a valid 2553 is treated as electing corporate status). Timing: file 2553 no more than 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to take effect (or any time during the preceding year). An S corporation can have no more than 100 shareholders, only eligible shareholders (individuals, estates, certain trusts, certain exempt organizations; no nonresident aliens), and one class of stock.

The comparison widget uses a simplified model: $200,000 of profit, $80,000 of salary for the S corporation and C corporation, a 24% ordinary rate and 15% rate on dividends. Result: sole proprietor or partnership $76,259; S corporation $60,240; C corporation paying out all after-tax profit as dividends $70,860. The S corporation wins by about $16,019 over the sole proprietor because only the $80,000 salary bears payroll tax.

But if the C corporation keeps the profit (0% dividends), its modeled tax is only $56,640 — and it is sitting on $94,800 of retained earnings. That's the deferral trade-off: a low current tax, with a second layer of tax later when the money comes out, and the accumulated-earnings tax if it piles up with no business reason.

What the model leaves out (so don't quote it on the exam): the §199A QBI deduction for pass-throughs, the Social Security wage base cap, the deduction for half of self-employment tax, the net investment income tax, state taxes, and the reasonable-compensation requirement for S-corporation owners (Lesson 12).

Open the widget

Step 1: §351 with control and $10,000 of boot.

Open D1.corp-general.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
ab40000
fmv100000
boot10000
control1

What you should see: Stock basis $40,000; the summary says deferred $50,000, taxed now $10,000.

Same facts but control fails (set the control drop-down to 'No').

Open D1.corp-general.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
ab40000
fmv100000
boot10000
control0

What you should see: No deferral: the full $60,000 is recognized and stock basis is $90,000.

Step 2: the $50,000 distribution ($30,000 E&P, $25,000 basis).

Open D1.corp-general.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
distAmt50000
ep30000
shBasis25000

What you should see: $30,000 dividend · $20,000 return of capital · $0 capital gain; basis afterward $5,000.

Step 3: a single-member LLC that files Form 2553 (tick the S-election box).

Open D1.entity-choice.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
formllc1
elS1

What you should see: Result: S corporation (2553; check eligibility). Try the multi-member LLC with no election to see the partnership default.

The comparison: $200,000 profit, $80,000 S-corp wages, all profit paid out as dividends.

Open D1.entity-tax-compare.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
profit200000
swage80000
divPct100
ordRate0.24
qdRate0.15

What you should see: Lowest modeled tax: S corp at $60,240. Slide the dividend % to 0 and the C corporation becomes the winner ($56,640) — with the retained-earnings caveat.

Practice questions

Answer all of them on paper first. Then tap Show answer & why: the rule, how to decide, why each choice is right or wrong, the numbers, and the IRS source. Want more? The practice set (20 questions) has more scenarios on this topic.

Q1. Ben transfers equipment (adjusted basis $40,000, FMV $100,000) to a new corporation for stock and $10,000 cash. Ben and Carla own 100% of the stock right after. What gain does Ben recognize, and what is his stock basis?

  1. $0 gain; basis $30,000
  2. $10,000 gain; basis $40,000
  3. $60,000 gain; basis $90,000
  4. $10,000 gain; basis $100,000
Show answer & why

Answer: B — $10,000 gain; basis $40,000

The rule, in plain English

§351: no gain unless boot is received (gain up to boot); stock basis = property basis − boot + gain recognized.

How to decide

  1. Transferors control 80% after?
  2. Gain = lesser of realized gain or boot.
  3. Stock basis = basis given − boot + gain.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Forgets the boot: cash received is taxed up to the realized gain, and recognized gain adds back to basis.
  • B — Correct. Control is met, so §351 applies and gain is recognized only up to the $10,000 boot. Basis = $40,000 − $10,000 + $10,000 = $40,000.
  • C — Wrong. Treats it as fully taxable, which happens only if §351 fails.
  • D — Wrong. Stock basis carries over the property's basis; it doesn't jump to FMV in a §351 exchange.

IRS source

Pub 542, Property Exchanged for Stock; IRC §351, §358.

Q2. Which fact would cause a §351 exchange of property for stock to be taxable?

  1. The transferors together own 85% of the stock
  2. A single person transfers all the property and receives 100% of the stock
  3. The transferors contribute both cash and property
  4. The transferors together own only 70% of the stock immediately after the exchange
Show answer & why

Answer: D — The transferors together own only 70% of the stock immediately after the exchange

The rule, in plain English

§351 needs the transferors to own at least 80% of voting power and 80% of each other class immediately after.

How to decide

  1. Add up what the transferors own right after.
  2. Under 80% → §351 fails and the exchange is taxable.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. 85% satisfies the 80% control requirement.
  • B — Wrong. A single transferor who owns everything afterward is in control.
  • C — Wrong. Mixing cash and property is fine. Cash itself is just stock-for-money.
  • D — Correct. Control requires at least 80% of the voting power and 80% of each other class, immediately after the exchange.

IRS source

Pub 542; IRC §368(c).

Q3. Kestrel, a C corporation with $30,000 of E&P, distributes $80,000 to Ben, whose stock basis is $25,000. How is it taxed?

  1. $30,000 dividend, $25,000 return of capital, $25,000 capital gain
  2. All $80,000 is a dividend
  3. $55,000 return of capital and $25,000 dividend
  4. $30,000 dividend, $50,000 return of capital
Show answer & why

Answer: A — $30,000 dividend, $25,000 return of capital, $25,000 capital gain

The rule, in plain English

C-corp distribution: dividend up to E&P, then tax-free return of capital up to stock basis, then capital gain.

How to decide

  1. Up to E&P → dividend.
  2. Next, up to basis → return of capital.
  3. Rest → capital gain.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Correct. Dividend up to E&P; then return of capital up to basis; the rest is capital gain.
  • B — Wrong. Dividends are limited to E&P.
  • C — Wrong. Reverses the order. The dividend comes first, from E&P.
  • D — Wrong. Return of capital can't exceed stock basis ($25,000); the excess is capital gain.

IRS source

Pub 542, Distributions; IRC §301, §316.

Q4. Two friends form a limited liability company under state law and file no entity-classification or S election. How is it taxed?

  1. As a C corporation on Form 1120
  2. As a disregarded entity on Schedule C
  3. As a partnership, reporting on Form 1065 with Schedules K-1
  4. As an S corporation because it is an LLC
Show answer & why

Answer: C — As a partnership, reporting on Form 1065 with Schedules K-1

The rule, in plain English

A multi-member LLC with no election is a partnership (Form 1065).

How to decide

  1. Members ≥ 2 and no Form 8832/2553 → partnership.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. That requires a Form 8832 election (or incorporating under state law).
  • B — Wrong. Disregarded status is for single-member LLCs.
  • C — Correct. A multi-member LLC is a partnership by default.
  • D — Wrong. An S election (Form 2553) is required and eligibility must be met.

IRS source

Form 8832 instructions (default classification).

Q5. Using the simplified model in the widget ($200,000 profit, $80,000 salary, 24% ordinary rate, 15% dividend rate, all after-tax profit paid out), how much lower is the S-corporation total than the sole proprietor's?

  1. $0
  2. About $16,019
  3. About $10,620
  4. About $28,259
Show answer & why

Answer: B — About $16,019

The rule, in plain English

(Widget model) A sole proprietor pays SE tax on 92.35% of all profit; an S corporation pays payroll tax only on the salary, so the S corp total is lower in this model.

How to decide

  1. Sole proprietor: SE tax on profit × 92.35% + income tax.
  2. S corp: payroll tax on salary + income tax on the rest.
  3. Subtract.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. The two are not equal: the sole proprietor pays self-employment tax on all profit.
  • B — Correct. Sole proprietor $76,259 (SE tax on 92.35% of profit plus income tax) versus S corporation $60,240 (payroll tax on only the $80,000 salary plus income tax).
  • C — Wrong. That's the difference between the C corporation and the S corporation, not sole prop and S corp.
  • D — Wrong. That's the sole proprietor's entire self-employment tax, not the difference.

IRS source

Widget model (D1.entity-tax-compare); Pub 334 (SE tax); Form 1120-S instructions (reasonable compensation).

Practice set (20 questions)

Same topic, more scenarios: 20 exam-style questions (17 with dollar amounts to work out step by step), each with the rule, how to decide, why every choice is right or wrong, and the IRS source.

Open the practice set (20 questions) →

Close the loop

Key rules in one line

§351 = 80% control, gain recognized up to boot, stock basis = AB − boot + gain; C-corp dist = dividend (E&P) → return of capital → capital gain; LLC default: 1 owner disregarded, 2+ partnership; Form 2553 within 2 mo. 15 days

Memory trigger: §351: 80% control defers the gain, boot gets taxed; C-corp checks pay dividends first, from E&P.

Missed one? Jot down why in My mistake notes — it helps you spot patterns.

Sources checked
  • Pub 542 (01/2024): §351 property exchanged for stock (80% control), basis of stock, loss on exchange, distributions (E&P), Form 5452, Form 1099-DIV, 21% rate.
  • Instructions for Form 1120 (2025): 21% rate, due date, charitable contribution limit (10%), NOL 80% limit, dividends-received deduction percentages.
  • Instructions for Form 2553 (2025): who may elect (100 shareholders, eligible shareholders, one class of stock), timing (2 months and 15 days).
  • Flagged: §357(c) liabilities in excess of basis, the accumulated-earnings tax details, and S-corporation built-in-gains tax were not researched here. The comparison widget is a simplified teaching model, not a tax calculation.

Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Numbers follow tax year 2025 (the Nov 2026 SEE tests 2025 law per the Candidate Information Bulletin).