Penalty and interest abatement — FTA, reasonable cause, §6404

Part 3 · Lesson 9 · Specific Areas of Representation · about 30 min

In plain English

Compute the late penalties first (FTF 5%/month, FTP 0.5%/month, each max 25%), then ask: First Time Abate eligible? If not, reasonable cause? Interest is abated only in narrow §6404 cases.

The story

Grace filed her 2024 return 3 months late (no extension) with $4,000 unpaid, and paid it with the return. She has never had a penalty before. Her mother was hospitalized in February.

Try it first 2 minutes · no peeking

Compute the FTF and FTP penalties for 3 months. Which abatement route is easiest?

Jot your answer down, then scroll. Being wrong first is the point — it makes the walk-through stick.

Walk-through, step by step

Step 1 — Compute

Each penalty caps at 25%. For a return more than 60 days late there is also a minimum FTF penalty (an inflation-indexed amount — not memorized here).

Step 2 — First Time Abate (administrative waiver)

Available for FTF, FTP and failure-to-deposit (and the §6698/§6699 partnership/S corporation late-filing penalties) if: no penalties in the prior 3 years (other than an estimated tax penalty), all required returns filed (or valid extensions), and tax paid or arranged to be paid. Not for accuracy penalties or the estimated tax penalty.

Step 3 — Reasonable cause

Ordinary business care and prudence but still couldn't comply: death or serious illness of the taxpayer or immediate family, fire/disaster, inability to get records. Ignorance of the law and reliance on a preparer to file generally aren't enough (United States v. Boyle).

Step 4 — Interest

Interest is generally not abated for reasonable cause. §6404(e): unreasonable error or delay by an IRS employee in a ministerial or managerial act, after the IRS contacted the taxpayer in writing. Interest on abated penalties is removed with the penalty. §6404(f): penalties due to erroneous written IRS advice.

Grace: FTA fits (clean 3-year history) — simplest. Request by phone or Form 843.

Practice questions

Answer on paper first, then tap Show answer & why. Want more? The practice set (20 questions).

Q1. Grace's return is 3 months late with $4,000 unpaid. What is the FTP penalty for those 3 months?

  1. $600
  2. $540
  3. $60
  4. $200
Show answer & why

Answer: C — $60

The rule, in plain English

FTP 0.5%/month.

How to decide

  1. 0.5% × 3 = 1.5%.
  2. 1.5% × $4,000 = $60.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. That's the combined total.
  • B — Wrong. That's the net FTF.
  • C — Correct. 0.5% × 3 × $4,000 = $60.
  • D — Wrong. Uses 5% for one month.

Worked numbers

0.5% × 3 × $4,000 = $60

IRS source

IRC §6651(a)(1), (a)(2), (c)(1); Pub. 17 / IRS.gov Penalties

Q2. Same facts. What is the net FTF penalty after the §6651(c)(1) reduction?

  1. $600
  2. $540
  3. $60
  4. $1,000
Show answer & why

Answer: B — $540

The rule, in plain English

FTF reduced by FTP for the same months.

How to decide

  1. 4.5% × 3 = 13.5%.
  2. 13.5% × $4,000 = $540.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Forgets to reduce by FTP.
  • B — Correct. 5% − 0.5% = 4.5% per month × 3 × $4,000.
  • C — Wrong. That's FTP.
  • D — Wrong. 25% max not reached.

Worked numbers

4.5% × 3 × $4,000 = $540

IRS source

IRC §6651(a)(1), (a)(2), (c)(1); Pub. 17 / IRS.gov Penalties

Q3. Grace has no penalties in the prior 3 years and is current on filing and payments. Which relief is simplest?

  1. First Time Abate
  2. §6404(e) interest abatement
  3. Innocent spouse relief
  4. Offer in compromise
Show answer & why

Answer: A — First Time Abate

The rule, in plain English

FTA: clean 3 years + compliance.

How to decide

  1. Prior penalties? None.
  2. Compliant? Yes → FTA.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Correct. FTA is an administrative waiver based on compliance history.
  • B — Wrong. That's IRS delay.
  • C — Wrong. Unrelated.
  • D — Wrong. Not needed.

IRS source

IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.1 (First Time Abate)

Q4. Which reason is generally not reasonable cause?

  1. Serious illness of the taxpayer
  2. A fire that destroyed records
  3. Death of an immediate family member
  4. Relying on the preparer to file the return on time
Show answer & why

Answer: D — Relying on the preparer to file the return on time

The rule, in plain English

Ordinary care & prudence; Boyle excludes relying on an agent to file.

How to decide

  1. Is it in the taxpayer's control? Yes → not RC.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Can be reasonable cause.
  • B — Wrong. Can be.
  • C — Wrong. Can be.
  • D — Correct. Boyle: the filing duty can't be delegated.

IRS source

United States v. Boyle, 469 U.S. 241 (1985); IRM 20.1.1.3.2

Q5. Which situation qualifies for interest abatement under §6404(e)?

  1. The taxpayer was ill
  2. An IRS employee's unreasonable delay in a ministerial act after the IRS contacted the taxpayer in writing
  3. The taxpayer didn't know the law
  4. Any IRS delay before any contact
Show answer & why

Answer: B — An IRS employee's unreasonable delay in a ministerial act after the IRS contacted the taxpayer in writing

The rule, in plain English

§6404(e): IRS ministerial/managerial error or delay.

How to decide

  1. Who caused the delay? IRS → maybe.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Interest isn't abated for reasonable cause.
  • B — Correct. §6404(e)(1).
  • C — Wrong. No.
  • D — Wrong. Must be after written contact.

IRS source

IRC §6404(e)

Practice set (20 questions)

Same topic, more scenarios, each with the rule, how to decide, why every choice is right or wrong, and the IRS source.

Open the practice set (20 questions) →

Close the loop

Key rules in one line

FTF 5%/month and FTP 0.5%/month, each up to 25%, FTF reduced by FTP for overlapping months (§6651); First Time Abate (3 clean years); reasonable cause; §6404(e)/(f) interest and erroneous-advice abatement; Form 843.

Memory trigger: 5 / 0.5 / 25. FTA first, then reasonable cause; interest only §6404.
Sources checked
  • IRC §6651(a)(1), (a)(2), (c)(1); Pub. 17 / IRS.gov Penalties
  • IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.1 (First Time Abate)
  • IRC §6404(e), (f), (h)
  • IRC §6654
  • Form 843 instructions
  • United States v. Boyle, 469 U.S. 241 (1985)

Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Practice items are original, not real exam questions. Every rule names its source — check anything surprising there. Inflation-indexed penalty amounts are left out on purpose.