In plain English
Know what counts as authority (Code, regs, rulings, cases — not textbooks), when the §7525 privilege applies (noncriminal tax advice only), and when you need the client's §7216 consent before using or sharing return information.
The story
Dana's client Omar is under exam. The revenue agent asks for Dana's notes of tax advice she gave Omar about a sale. Separately, a mortgage broker emails Dana asking for Omar's last return. And Omar asks whether a blog post supports his deduction.
Walk-through, step by step
Step 1 — Ranking authority
- Internal Revenue Code (statute)Highest
- Treasury regulations (final, temporary; proposed regs are weaker)
- Revenue rulings & revenue proceduresBinding on IRS; taxpayers may rely
- Court decisions (Supreme Court binds all)
- PLRs / TAMsOnly the requesting taxpayer may rely, but count as 'authority' for §6662
Not authority (Reg. §1.6662-4(d)(3)(iii)): treatises, legal periodicals, legal opinions or other opinions of tax professionals — and blog posts.
Step 2 — §7525 privilege
Communications about tax advice between a taxpayer and a federally authorized tax practitioner (EA, CPA, attorney) get the same protection as attorney–client privilege — but only in noncriminal tax matters before the IRS or noncriminal federal court tax proceedings. It does not cover written communications promoting tax shelters, and information for return preparation is generally not privileged.
Step 3 — §7216 consent
A preparer may not use or disclose return information except as allowed by regulations — usually with a written, signed and dated consent obtained before the use or disclosure. If the consent states no duration, it lasts one year. Knowing/reckless violation: criminal (§7216); civil penalty (§6713).
Trap: §7525 is not a criminal-case shield. If the matter turns criminal, the privilege doesn't apply.
Practice questions
Answer on paper first, then tap Show answer & why. Want more? The practice set (20 questions).
Q1. Which is not treated as 'authority' when deciding substantial authority under §6662?
- A tax treatise or a tax professional's opinion
- A revenue ruling
- A Tax Court decision
- A private letter ruling issued to another taxpayer
Show answer & why
Answer: A — A tax treatise or a tax professional's opinion
The rule, in plain English
Authority = Code, regs, rulings, procedures, cases, legislative history, PLRs/TAMs, etc.; not opinions.
How to decide
- Find the non-legal source.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Correct. Reg. §1.6662-4(d)(3)(iii) excludes treatises, periodicals and professional opinions.
- B — Wrong. Listed as authority.
- C — Wrong. Listed as authority.
- D — Wrong. PLRs are listed authority for this purpose.
IRS source
Treas. Reg. §1.6662-4(d)(3)(iii)
Part 3 Lesson 6: walk-through Missed it? Add to my notes
Q2. The revenue agent asks for Dana's memo of tax advice to Omar in a civil exam. Is the memo protected?
- No — only attorneys have privilege
- Yes — the §7525 federally authorized tax practitioner privilege can apply to tax advice in a noncriminal matter
- Yes — in all matters including criminal
- No — privilege never applies before the IRS
Show answer & why
Answer: B — Yes — the §7525 federally authorized tax practitioner privilege can apply to tax advice in a noncriminal matter
The rule, in plain English
§7525: tax advice, noncriminal, FATP.
How to decide
- Advice? Yes.
- Criminal? No.
- → privilege may apply.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. §7525 extends it to EAs and CPAs.
- B — Correct. §7525 extends privilege to FATPs for noncriminal tax matters.
- C — Wrong. Not criminal.
- D — Wrong. §7525 applies before the IRS.
IRS source
IRC §7525
Part 3 Lesson 6: walk-through Missed it? Add to my notes
Q3. A mortgage broker asks Dana for Omar's return. What does she need first?
- Nothing — Omar's broker is a business partner
- A Form 8821 from the broker
- Omar's written, signed and dated consent to that disclosure
- Permission from the IRS
Show answer & why
Answer: C — Omar's written, signed and dated consent to that disclosure
The rule, in plain English
Preparer disclosure → §7216 consent before disclosing.
How to decide
- Who is disclosing? The preparer.
- Is it for preparation? No → consent.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. Consent is still required.
- B — Wrong. 8821 is for IRS disclosure, not preparer disclosure.
- C — Correct. §7216 regulations require consent before disclosure for non-preparation purposes.
- D — Wrong. The client's consent is what's required.
IRS source
Treas. Reg. §301.7216-3
Part 3 Lesson 6: walk-through Missed it? Add to my notes
Q4. A §7216 consent does not state how long it lasts. How long is it valid?
- Until revoked
- Three years
- Only for the current filing season
- One year from the date signed
Show answer & why
Answer: D — One year from the date signed
The rule, in plain English
No stated duration → 1 year.
How to decide
- Duration stated? No → 1 year.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. There is a default limit.
- B — Wrong. Not the default.
- C — Wrong. The default is one year.
- D — Correct. Reg. §301.7216-3 provides a one-year default duration.
IRS source
Treas. Reg. §301.7216-3(b)(5)
Part 3 Lesson 6: walk-through Missed it? Add to my notes
Q5. Which IRS document may only be relied on by the taxpayer who requested it?
- A revenue ruling
- A Treasury regulation
- A revenue procedure
- A private letter ruling
Show answer & why
Answer: D — A private letter ruling
The rule, in plain English
PLR = only for the requester.
How to decide
- Published? No → PLR.
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A — Wrong. Published guidance; all taxpayers may rely.
- B — Wrong. Applies to all.
- C — Wrong. Published guidance.
- D — Correct. §6110(k)(3): written determinations may not be used or cited as precedent.
IRS source
IRC §6110(k)(3)
Part 3 Lesson 6: walk-through Missed it? Add to my notes
Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Practice items are original, not real exam questions. Every rule names its source — check anything surprising there. Inflation-indexed penalty amounts are left out on purpose.