The Garcias' rentals: passive losses, the $25,000 allowance, and the beach cottage

Lesson 8 · Specialized Returns and Taxpayers · about 50 min · tax year 2025

Today's idea

Rental losses are passive by default and can only offset passive income — with one big exception: up to $25,000 for people who actively participate, phased out between $100,000 and $150,000 of MAGI. A second trap: if you use a rental as your own home too much, the loss rules change completely.

The story

Elena and Marco Garcia file jointly. Elena is a dentist; Marco manages the two rentals.

Rental #1 is a duplex they rent to tenants all year. It took in $24,000 and had $36,000 of expenses (including depreciation): a $12,000 loss. Marco chooses tenants, sets rent, and approves repairs. Their MAGI is $110,000 (before considering this loss).

Rental #2 is a beach cottage. It was rented at fair prices for 100 days; the family used it for 30 days. The cottage had $26,000 of expenses, and rental receipts of $13,000.

Their friend Nora is a full-time real estate agent who spends 1,200 hours a year managing and showing properties she owns, and she has no other job.

Try it first 2 minutes · no peeking

Before reading: (1) How much of the duplex's $12,000 loss can the Garcias deduct against Elena's dental income this year? (2) Is the beach cottage a "rental" or a "home" for tax purposes, and how much of its $26,000 of expenses can they use?

Hint for (2): count the days, and compare personal days to the greater of two numbers.

Jot your answer down, then scroll. Being wrong first is the point — it makes the walk-through stick.

Walk-through

Three filters, in order: is it passive? does the $25,000 allowance apply? is the property a home for too many personal days?

Filter 1 — Passive by default

Rental real estate is a passive activity, and passive losses can only offset passive income. Whatever can't be used is suspended and carried forward. The exceptions are: the $25,000 special allowance, or qualifying as a real estate professional.

Filter 2 — The $25,000 allowance

If you (or your spouse) actively participated — at least 10% ownership plus real management decisions like approving tenants, setting rent, and approving repairs — you can deduct up to $25,000 of rental loss against other income ($12,500 for married filing separately and living apart all year). The allowance is reduced by 50 cents for every dollar of MAGI over $100,000 and is gone at $150,000. Active participation is a lower bar than material participation.

Their loss ($12,000) is smaller than the allowance ($20,000), so all $12,000 is deductible. If the loss had been $30,000, only $20,000 could be deducted now and the remaining $10,000 would be suspended. At MAGI of $150,000 the allowance is $0; at $130,000 it's $10,000.

Real estate professional (Nora). Rental real estate isn't automatically passive for a person who (1) spends more than half of her personal services in real property trades or businesses in which she materially participates, and (2) spends more than 750 hours a year in them. Nora's 1,200 hours and full-time focus meet both tests, so her rentals are non-passive if she also materially participates in the rentals. Then the $25,000 limit and MAGI phase-out don't apply to her. Services as an employee don't count unless she owns more than 5% of the employer.

Filter 3 — Is the cottage a rental or a home?

A dwelling unit is used as a home if personal use exceeds the greater of 14 days or 10% of the days rented at a fair price. Family use counts as personal use, and so does use by anyone at less than a fair rent. The cottage: rented 100 days; personal use 30 days. 10% × 100 = 10, so the greater of 14 and 10 is 14. 30 > 14, so the cottage is used as a home.

When a unit is used as a home and rented 15 days or more, you first split expenses by days: rental days ÷ total days = 100 ÷ 130, so $26,000 × 100/130 = $20,000 is the rental share. But the deduction can't create a loss: it is limited to the rental income ($13,000). So they deduct $13,000 and the extra $7,000 carries to next year (subject to the same limit). No loss, and no $25,000 allowance for this unit.

Change one fact: if the family had used it only 12 days, 12 is not more than the greater of 14 and 10, so it would not be used as a home; it becomes an ordinary rental and the loss rules from Filter 2 apply. With 200 rental days and 18 personal days: 18 ≤ the greater of 14 and 20, so again not a home.

Under 15 days of rental: if you rent a home for fewer than 15 days in the year, you don't report the rent as income and you don't deduct rental expenses. The exam loves this (it's called the 14-day rule).

Open the widget

The duplex: 365 rental days, no personal use, $24,000 rents, $36,000 expenses, MAGI $110,000, active participation.

Open D3.rental.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
rentDays365
persDays0
income24000
exp36000
magi110000
active1

What you should see: Deductible $12,000 with the allowance shown as $20,000 of $25,000.

A bigger loss ($30,000) at the same MAGI — the allowance binds.

Open D3.rental.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
rentDays365
persDays0
income10000
exp40000
magi110000
active1

What you should see: Deductible $20,000; the other $10,000 is suspended.

The phase-out fully applied: same $12,000 loss at MAGI $150,000.

Open D3.rental.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
rentDays365
persDays0
income24000
exp36000
magi150000
active1

What you should see: Deductible $0 (the allowance is gone).

The cottage: 100 rental days, 30 personal days. The yellow box says personal use exceeds the limit.

Open D3.rental.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
rentDays100
persDays30
income13000
exp20000
magi110000
active1

What you should see: Deductible $0 — a home can't create a loss for the allowance. (The widget shows the days test; the 100/130 expense split is explained in the lesson and is not computed by the widget.)

Practice questions

Answer all of them on paper first. Then tap Show answer & why: the rule, how to decide, why each choice is right or wrong, the numbers, and the IRS source. Want more? The practice set (22 questions) has more scenarios on this topic.

Q1. The Garcias (MAGI $110,000, married filing jointly) actively participate in a duplex with a $30,000 net rental loss and have no passive income. How much of the loss can they deduct this year?

  1. $25,000
  2. $20,000
  3. $30,000
  4. $0
Show answer & why

Answer: B — $20,000

The rule, in plain English

Active participants get up to $25,000 of rental losses against other income, reduced by 50% of MAGI over $100,000.

How to decide

  1. Active participation?
  2. Reduction = 50% × (MAGI − $100,000).
  3. Allowed = $25,000 − reduction, but not more than the loss.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Forgets the MAGI phase-out. Above $100,000 the allowance drops by 50 cents per dollar.
  • B — Correct. The $25,000 allowance is reduced by 50% × ($110,000 − $100,000) = $5,000 to $20,000. The remaining $10,000 is suspended.
  • C — Wrong. Treats the whole loss as deductible. Passive losses are limited.
  • D — Wrong. Would be right at MAGI $150,000 or more, or without active participation.

IRS source

Pub 925 (2025), special $25,000 allowance.

Q2. At what MAGI does the $25,000 special rental-loss allowance disappear completely (for a joint filer who actively participates)?

  1. $100,000
  2. $125,000
  3. $200,000
  4. $150,000
Show answer & why

Answer: D — $150,000

The rule, in plain English

The $25,000 allowance phases out completely at $150,000 MAGI (50% of the excess over $100,000).

How to decide

  1. $25,000 ÷ 50% = $50,000 of phase-out range.
  2. $100,000 + $50,000 = $150,000.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. That's where the phase-out starts.
  • B — Wrong. Halfway point; the allowance is $12,500 there.
  • C — Wrong. That's the higher range for rehabilitation credits, not the loss allowance.
  • D — Correct. The allowance begins phasing out at $100,000 and is reduced by 50% of the excess, so it reaches zero at $150,000.

IRS source

Pub 925 (2025).

Q3. A beach house is rented at fair rent for 100 days, used personally for 30 days, and has $26,000 of expenses with $13,000 of rental income. What is the deductible rental expense for the year?

  1. $13,000
  2. $20,000
  3. $26,000
  4. $0
Show answer & why

Answer: A — $13,000

The rule, in plain English

If a dwelling is used as a home, rental expenses are allocated by days and limited to rental income.

How to decide

  1. Personal days > greater of 14 or 10% of rental days → home.
  2. Rental share = expenses × rental days ÷ total use days.
  3. Deductions limited to rental income.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Correct. It's used as a home (30 days > greater of 14 and 10). Rental share of expenses is $20,000, but deductions are limited to rental income of $13,000.
  • B — Wrong. Stops at the rental-share calculation and forgets the limit to rental income for a dwelling used as a home.
  • C — Wrong. Deducts all expenses even though personal days are part of the use.
  • D — Wrong. Only rentals under 15 days get zero deduction; this one was rented 100 days.

IRS source

Pub 527 (2025), Dwelling Unit Used as a Home.

Q4. A vacation home is rented at fair rent for 200 days and used by the owner for 18 days. Is it treated as a 'home' under the personal-use test?

  1. Yes — 18 days is more than 14
  2. Yes — any personal use makes it a home
  3. No — 18 days is not more than the greater of 14 days or 10% of 200 (20 days)
  4. Only if the owner's family also used it
Show answer & why

Answer: C — No — 18 days is not more than the greater of 14 days or 10% of 200 (20 days)

The rule, in plain English

Home test: personal days must exceed the greater of 14 days or 10% of fair-rental days.

How to decide

  1. 10% of rental days vs. 14: take the greater.
  2. Personal days above that → home; otherwise not.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. 14 is only one of the two numbers; you use the greater.
  • B — Wrong. Personal use must exceed the threshold.
  • C — Correct. The threshold is the greater of 14 or 10% of rental days: 20 here. 18 doesn't exceed 20.
  • D — Wrong. Family use counts as personal use, but the test is the day count.

IRS source

Pub 527 (2025).

Q5. Nora works full time as a real estate agent, spending 1,200 hours a year in real property businesses in which she materially participates, and has no other job. Her rental loss is $40,000 and her MAGI is $170,000. How is the loss generally treated?

  1. Fully disallowed, because her MAGI is over $150,000
  2. Non-passive — she qualifies as a real estate professional (more than half her time and more than 750 hours), so the allowance phase-out doesn't apply
  3. Limited to $25,000 because she is a rental owner
  4. Passive, because rental activities are always passive
Show answer & why

Answer: B — Non-passive — she qualifies as a real estate professional (more than half her time and more than 750 hours), so the allowance phase-out doesn't apply

The rule, in plain English

A real estate professional (more than half of personal services and more than 750 hours in real property businesses with material participation) treats those rentals as non-passive.

How to decide

  1. More than half of working time in real property businesses?
  2. More than 750 hours? Material participation in the rental?
  3. Yes → non-passive; the $25,000 phase-out doesn't apply.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. That limit applies to the $25,000 allowance, which she doesn't need.
  • B — Correct. Real estate professional status treats rentals in which she materially participates as non-passive.
  • C — Wrong. The $25,000 cap is part of the allowance, not the real estate professional rules.
  • D — Wrong. Rentals are passive by default, but the real estate professional exception overrides.

IRS source

Pub 925 (2025), real estate professional.

Practice set (22 questions)

Same topic, more scenarios: 22 exam-style questions (15 with dollar amounts to work out step by step), each with the rule, how to decide, why every choice is right or wrong, and the IRS source.

Open the practice set (22 questions) →

Close the loop

Key rules in one line

rental = passive; $25k allowance needs ACTIVE participation, phases out 50¢/$ from MAGI $100k to $150k; 'home' = personal days > greater of 14 or 10% of rental days; REP = >750 hrs AND >half of services

Memory trigger: Passive by default; $25,000 melts away between $100k and $150k; 'greater of 14 or 10%' decides if the cottage is your home.

Missed one? Jot down why in My mistake notes — it helps you spot patterns.

Sources checked
  • Pub 527 (2025): residential rental property; dwelling unit used as a home (14 days / 10%); days of personal use; expenses limited to rental income; rented fewer than 15 days; active participation and the $25,000 allowance; real estate professional.
  • Pub 925 (2025): passive activity and at-risk rules, special $25,000 allowance, real estate professional qualifications (more than half of personal services and more than 750 hours).
  • Not verified in a downloaded source: the exact Pub 527 ordering of expenses (interest/taxes first) in the limited-to-rental-income case; the lesson uses a simple days-based split.

Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Numbers follow tax year 2025 (the Nov 2026 SEE tests 2025 law per the Candidate Information Bulletin).