Three small employers, three plans: SEP, SIMPLE, and 401(k)

Lesson 7 · Specialized Returns and Taxpayers · about 50 min · tax year 2025

Today's idea

A business retirement plan has two separate limits that people mix up: how much an employee can defer from pay (the elective-deferral limit, plus catch-up) and how much the total annual additions to one person's account can be (the §415(c) limit). Catch-up contributions sit outside the annual-additions limit.

The story

Three small-business owners ask the same EA for advice on 2025 contributions.

Sam owns his one-person design business through his own corporation. He is paid $120,000 and wants the simplest possible plan with no employee deferrals: a SEP-IRA.

Tina runs a 12-person bakery ($80,000 salary for her key baker, age 45). She wants a low-paperwork plan where employees defer and she matches: a SIMPLE IRA.

Uma owns a 60-person manufacturer and wants a 401(k) with a 25%-of-pay employer contribution. Her plant manager Victor earns $200,000 and is 55. Another employee, Wanda, is 61 and earns $200,000 too. Finally, a part-timer Xavier, age 40, earns just $30,000.

Try it first 2 minutes · no peeking

Before reading: (1) What's the most Sam's business can put into his SEP for 2025 if the plan uses 25% of pay? (2) If Victor defers the most he's allowed, how large can the company's 25% contribution be, and what's the grand total in his account for 2025?

Hint for (2): does the age-50 catch-up count toward the $70,000 limit?

Jot your answer down, then scroll. Being wrong first is the point — it makes the walk-through stick.

Walk-through

Keep the 2025 numbers on one sheet: elective deferral $23,500 (401(k)); catch-up (age 50+) $7,500; higher catch-up at ages 60–63: $11,250; SIMPLE deferral $16,500, catch-up $3,500 ($5,250 at 60–63); annual additions limit (§415(c)): lesser of $70,000 or 100% of compensation; compensation cap: $350,000; SEP employer limit: lesser of 25% of compensation or $70,000.

SEP-IRA — Sam (employer-only)

Only the employer contributes. The limit is the lesser of 25% of the employee's compensation (compensation capped at $350,000) or $70,000. Sam: 25% × $120,000 = $30,000. Even at $350,000 of pay, 25% is $87,500, so the $70,000 cap controls ($70,000). Eligible employees must be at least 21, have worked for you in 3 of the last 5 years, and have earned at least $750 in 2025. Contributions are due by the employer's return due date, including extensions. (Self-employed owners use a reduced rate; not needed here.)

SIMPLE IRA — Tina's baker

Employers with 100 or fewer employees who earned $5,000 or more can set up a SIMPLE IRA. The employee defers up to $16,500, plus $3,500 if age 50 or over. The employer must either match dollar-for-dollar up to 3% of pay or make a 2% nonelective contribution for everyone. For the $80,000 baker: 3% is $2,400. If she defers $16,500, the match is $2,400, for a total of $18,900. If she defers nothing, the match is $0 — no deferral, no match. Salary deferrals must be deposited within 30 days after month end. A SIMPLE IRA must be set up between January 1 and October 1 (for a new employer, as soon as administratively feasible).

401(k) — Victor, Wanda, and Xavier

Victor's regular deferral is $23,500 plus a $7,500 catch-up = $31,000 of his own money. The employer 25% of $200,000 is $46,500 — and it fits, because the §415(c) limit compares the non-catch-up total against $70,000: $23,500 + $46,500 = $70,000, exactly at the limit. The catch-up comes on top. Total account additions for 2025: $77,500.

Wanda (61) falls in the 60–63 window, so her catch-up is $11,250, not $7,500 — if the plan allows it. She defers $34,750 (= $23,500 + $11,250); the employer adds $46,500; total $81,250.

Xavier (40, $30,000): the §415(c) limit is the lesser of $70,000 or 100% of his pay = $30,000. He defers $23,500; a 100% employer contribution can add at most $6,500, because the total can't exceed his pay. Total $30,000.

The mistake to avoid: subtracting the whole deferral (including catch-up) from $70,000 to find the employer room. Catch-up is outside the limit. (The widget had this bug; it's fixed.)

Another exam favorite: the SEP is employer-only (no employee deferrals in a standard SEP), the SIMPLE has the lowest limits, and only a 401(k) type plan lets the higher $70,000 + catch-up picture happen.

Open the widget

Sam's SEP: $120,000 of pay, 25% employer contribution.

Open D3.retirement-plans.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
plansep
comp120000
def0
age45
erPct25

What you should see: Employer contribution $30,000, total $30,000.

Tina's baker, SIMPLE, defers the full $16,500.

Open D3.retirement-plans.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
plansimple
comp80000
def16500
age45
erPct25

What you should see: Max deferral $16,500, match $2,400, total $18,900. Set deferral to 0 and the match disappears.

Victor's 401(k): age 55, 25% employer contribution.

Open D3.retirement-plans.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
plan401k
comp200000
def31000
age55
erPct25

What you should see: Max deferral $31,000, employer $46,500, total $77,500.

Wanda at 61: the higher catch-up window.

Open D3.retirement-plans.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
plan401k
comp200000
def34750
age61
erPct25

What you should see: Max deferral $34,750, total $81,250.

Practice questions

Answer all of them on paper first. Then tap Show answer & why: the rule, how to decide, why each choice is right or wrong, the numbers, and the IRS source. Want more? The practice set (21 questions) has more scenarios on this topic.

Q1. Sam, a sole employee of his own corporation, is paid $120,000. His corporation makes the maximum SEP contribution at 25% of pay for 2025. What is the contribution?

  1. $23,500
  2. $70,000
  3. $30,000
  4. $16,500
Show answer & why

Answer: C — $30,000

The rule, in plain English

SEP: employer contributes up to 25% of compensation, capped at $70,000 for 2025.

How to decide

  1. 25% × compensation.
  2. Compare with $70,000; take the smaller.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. That is the 401(k) elective-deferral limit, not a SEP figure.
  • B — Wrong. That's the cap, which doesn't bind at $120,000 of pay.
  • C — Correct. 25% × $120,000 = $30,000, which is below the $70,000 cap.
  • D — Wrong. That's the SIMPLE deferral limit.

IRS source

Pub 560 (2025), SEP limits.

Q2. A 45-year-old earns $80,000 in a SIMPLE IRA plan with a 3% dollar-for-dollar match. She defers $10,000. What does the employer contribute?

  1. $10,000
  2. $2,400
  3. $1,600
  4. $0
Show answer & why

Answer: B — $2,400

The rule, in plain English

SIMPLE IRA 3% match: dollar-for-dollar on deferrals up to 3% of compensation.

How to decide

  1. 3% × compensation.
  2. Match = smaller of that or the employee's deferral.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. The match isn't 100% of the deferral; it stops at 3% of pay.
  • B — Correct. The match is dollar-for-dollar on deferrals up to 3% of pay: 3% × $80,000 = $2,400, and her $10,000 deferral exceeds that.
  • C — Wrong. That's 2% of pay, the nonelective alternative, not the match.
  • D — Wrong. She did defer, so the match applies.

IRS source

Pub 560 (2025), SIMPLE matching contributions.

Q3. Victor, 55, earns $200,000 in a 401(k) where the employer contributes 25% of pay. He defers the maximum allowed (regular plus catch-up). What are the total 2025 contributions to his account?

  1. $77,500
  2. $70,000
  3. $81,000
  4. $55,000
Show answer & why

Answer: A — $77,500

The rule, in plain English

Deferrals plus employer contributions must fit within $70,000 (2025); age-50+ catch-up ($7,500) goes on top.

How to decide

  1. $23,500 regular deferral.
  2. Employer adds up to $70,000 − deferral (or its formula, if lower).
  3. Add the catch-up on top.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Correct. The regular deferral plus the employer contribution must fit in $70,000, so the employer can add $70,000 − $23,500 = $46,500 (less than the full 25% = $50,000). Add the $7,500 catch-up on top: $23,500 + $46,500 + $7,500 = $77,500.
  • B — Wrong. Leaves the catch-up out; it is additional to the §415(c) limit.
  • C — Wrong. Takes the full 25% employer contribution ($50,000) plus $31,000. That breaks the $70,000 annual-additions limit (non-catch-up $73,500).
  • D — Wrong. Uses 25% of pay as a cap on everything.

IRS source

Pub 560 (2025), annual additions and catch-up limits.

Q4. Wanda, 61, is in a 401(k) that allows the enhanced catch-up for ages 60–63. What is the maximum she can defer from her own pay for 2025 (compensation is high enough)?

  1. $31,000
  2. $23,500
  3. $70,000
  4. $34,750
Show answer & why

Answer: D — $34,750

The rule, in plain English

For 2025, ages 60–63 get an enhanced catch-up of $11,250 (if the plan allows) on top of the $23,500 deferral limit.

How to decide

  1. Age 60–63 at year end? Use $11,250 catch-up.
  2. Total = $23,500 + $11,250.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. That's the ordinary age-50 catch-up ($7,500) and misses the higher window.
  • B — Wrong. That's the regular limit with no catch-up.
  • C — Wrong. That's the annual additions cap, not a deferral limit.
  • D — Correct. $23,500 regular + $11,250 super catch-up for ages 60–63.

IRS source

Pub 560 (2025), catch-up for ages 60–63.

Q5. Xavier, 40, earns $30,000 in a 401(k). He defers $23,500, and the employer wants to add as much as possible. What is the most the employer can add?

  1. $46,500
  2. $6,500
  3. $0
  4. $30,000
Show answer & why

Answer: B — $6,500

The rule, in plain English

Annual additions are limited to the lesser of $70,000 or 100% of compensation.

How to decide

  1. Limit = lesser of $70,000 or pay.
  2. Employer room = limit − employee deferral.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Uses $70,000 − $23,500 and ignores the 100%-of-pay cap.
  • B — Correct. The annual-additions limit is the lesser of $70,000 or 100% of pay: $30,000. $30,000 − $23,500 = $6,500.
  • C — Wrong. His deferral uses most of his pay but there's still room under the cap.
  • D — Wrong. That's his total pay; his own deferral already used part of the limit.

IRS source

Pub 560 (2025), annual additions.

Practice set (21 questions)

Same topic, more scenarios: 21 exam-style questions (16 with dollar amounts to work out step by step), each with the rule, how to decide, why every choice is right or wrong, and the IRS source.

Open the practice set (21 questions) →

Close the loop

Key rules in one line

SEP = employer only, ≤25% pay/$70k; SIMPLE $16.5k (+$3.5k), match ≤3% of pay; 401(k) $23.5k (+$7.5k, +$11.25k at 60–63); §415(c) = lesser of $70k or 100% of pay EXCLUDING catch-up

Memory trigger: Catch-up rides outside the $70,000 roof; SEP is the employer's check only; SIMPLE match needs a deferral.

Missed one? Jot down why in My mistake notes — it helps you spot patterns.

Sources checked
  • Pub 560 (2025): limits tables (SEP 25%/$70,000; SIMPLE $16,500; 401(k) $23,500; catch-ups $7,500 / $3,500; ages 60–63 $11,250 / $5,250); eligible employee definition; SIMPLE setup dates; annual additions; compensation cap $350,000.
  • Pub 560 also lists 2026 figures; they are not used here because the Nov 2026 exam tests tax year 2025.
  • Not verified: the plan-document requirement that a 401(k) must allow the ages 60–63 catch-up (Pub 560 says 'if the plan allows').

Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Numbers follow tax year 2025 (the Nov 2026 SEE tests 2025 law per the Candidate Information Bulletin).