Late filing vs late paying

Failure-to-file · failure-to-pay · interest — how additions pile up

In plain English

If you owe tax and are late, three additions can grow: failure to file (FTF) at about 5% per month of unpaid tax (capped at 25%), failure to pay (FTP) at about 0.5% per month (also capped at 25%), and interest on underpayments.

When the return is not filed, FTF is reduced by FTP for the same overlapping months (IRC §6651(c)(1)) — you do not stack a full 5% + 0.5% independently. Gross FTF hits its 25% cap in 5 months and then stops growing; it does not shrink. Filing late hurts much faster than paying late alone.

How to walk through it: Pick the return type first (regimes differ). For individuals (and similar §6651 returns), enter unpaid tax and months late, then toggle whether the return was filed. Watch gross FTF, the overlapping-month FTP offset, net FTF, FTP, and approximate interest. This is a teaching tool — not a live IRS calculator.

Return type

Penalties are not identical for every form. Choose the regime you are studying.

Your scenario · Form 1040 teaching model (§6651)

Teaching model of civil penalty rates under IRC §6651 — not a live IRS calculator. Interest below is a simple approximation (no daily compounding; not official IRS interest tables).

Unpaid tax and timing
Months late (after due date) 6 months
Whole months for FTF / FTP percentage caps in this sketch (a fraction of a month counts as a full month under §6651).
Assumed underpayment interest rate (annual) 8.00% / year
Teaching default only — not a live IRS underpayment rate feed and not daily compounding.
Return status

Key totals

Tax + all additions (net FTF + FTP + approx. interest)
—
Gross FTF (capped)
—
5%/mo · max 25% · does not shrink
§6651(c)(1) reduction
—
FTP for overlapping months only
Net FTF after reduction
—
What is added for late filing
FTP penalty
—
0.5%/mo · max 25%
Interest (approx.)
—
Teaching rate · not IRS tables
LineAmount
Gross FTF (5%/mo, capped at 25%)—
Minus §6651(c)(1) reduction (FTP for months both apply)—
Net FTF after reduction—
FTP (0.5%/mo, capped at 25%)—
Interest (simple teaching approx.)—
Net FTF FTP Interest Original tax

Stacked growth over months

Chart uses net FTF (after overlapping-month reduction). Gross FTF is capped and non-decreasing — after month 5 it stays flat; only FTP and interest keep growing. Net FTF should not look like the FTF rate/cap is falling.

Additions by month · stacked area (net FTF + FTP + interest)
Gross FTF vs net FTF vs FTP (lines · teaching check)
Grouped bars · net FTF / FTP / interest by unpaid tax
Donut · composition of additions
Common exam mistake: Treating FTF and FTP as independently stacked full rates, or thinking FTF “shrinks” after month 5. Under IRC §6651, gross FTF is 5%/month up to 25% and then stops. When both penalties apply, FTF is reduced by FTP for the same months only (§6651(c)(1)) — so net FTF often lands at 22.5% after five months and then holds. Extra months add FTP (until 25%) and interest; they do not claw back more FTF. Minimum FTF dollar floors (e.g. the inflation-adjusted floor when a return is more than 60 days late) are not modeled here.
← All study tools Diagnostic home

Teaching tool only — not tax software. IRC §6651 teaching rates for the interactive calculator; partnership/S corp late-filing uses §6698 / §6699 (explained above, not calculated here). Interest is a simple approximation, not daily compounding or official IRS interest tables. Verify against current IRS notices before advising a client.