Employee or contractor?

Worker classification, who pays FICA / FUTA / SE tax, and S-corp reasonable pay

In plain English

The label on the check — W-2 or 1099 — does not decide the tax answer. Look at how the work actually runs: who controls the methods and schedule (behavioral), who bears tools and profit-or-loss risk (financial), and how permanent or central the relationship looks (relationship). That common-law cluster decides employee vs independent contractor (IC).

If someone is an employee, the employer withholds and matches FICA (Social Security and Medicare) and generally pays FUTA (federal unemployment). If someone is truly an IC (or a sole proprietor), they usually pay self-employment (SE) tax on net earnings — roughly both halves of FICA — on Schedule SE.

For an S corporation, owners who do real work must take reasonable compensation (W-2 wages subject to employment tax) before treating leftovers as distributions. Token wages plus big distributions is a classic exam red flag.

How to walk through it: Check the factors that lean employee vs contractor — no single checkbox wins; weigh the cluster. Then remember who pays what: employee → employer FICA match + FUTA; IC / sole prop → SE tax. Finally, stress-test an S-corp picture: wages vs a market wage for the services actually performed.

Who pays what (high level)

Calm cheat-sheet for the employment-tax side of Part 2 — not a payroll calculator.

Weigh the classification factors

Check what fits the facts. Scores are a teaching lean — the exam wants the idea, not a magic formula.

Behavioral · financial · relationship
Teaching lean
—
Employee-leaning score
0
IC-leaning score
0
Employee lean0%
IC lean0%
Factor tug-of-war

S-corp reasonable compensation checkpoint

Compare W-2 wages to a market wage for the services. Large distributions with tiny wages are the trap.

Numbers for the owner who works in the business
Compensation flag
—
Wages as a share of market: —
Wages vs market—
Wages · market · distributions
Common exam mistake: Believing a 1099 label controls classification — substance of behavioral, financial, and relationship factors does. Mixing up who pays FICA vs SE tax. And for S corps: zero or token W-2 wages with large distributions while the owner performs substantial services — expect recharacterization / employment-tax themes.
← All study tools Diagnostic home

Teaching tool only — not tax software or a formal Form SS-8 analysis. Factor weights are illustrative for the Enrolled Agent Part 2 exam.