Nadia's year-end: cash vs accrual, changing methods, and counting the shelves

Lesson 4 · Business Tax Preparation · about 55 min · tax year 2025

Today's idea

Your accounting method decides which year income and expenses land in. Cash looks at money in and out; accrual looks at rights and obligations. Changing methods needs Form 3115 and a catch-up called a §481(a) adjustment. And when you sell goods, how you value the leftover shelf (FIFO or LIFO) changes cost of goods sold.

The story

Nadia Okafor owns Pinecrest Supply, selling cabinet hardware and doing small installs. It's December 31.

During December she finished installs worth $12,000 in total. A customer handed her a $2,000 check on December 29, which she left in the desk drawer and didn't deposit until January. The other $10,000 was paid January 10. Also, a cleaning service worked in December and billed her $3,000, which she paid in January.

Later in the story Nadia turns Pinecrest into a C corporation and it grows fast, which raises the question of whether it can still use the cash method. And on the shelves: she started the year with $80,000 of hardware, bought $200,000 more during the year, and has 200 units left at year end. Her early-in-the-year cost was $250 a unit; her latest purchases cost $320 a unit.

Try it first 2 minutes · no peeking

Before reading: (1) On a cash return, how much of the December work counts as 2025 income, and is the $3,000 cleaning bill deductible in 2025? What about on an accrual return? (2) Nadia's ending inventory is 200 units. Would FIFO or LIFO give her the larger cost of goods sold when prices are rising, and by roughly how much?

Hint for (1): one word matters — constructive.

Jot your answer down, then scroll. Being wrong first is the point — it makes the walk-through stick.

Walk-through

Think of the year as a bucket. The method decides which bucket each dollar falls into. Nothing changes about the real cash; only the tax year it's reported in.

Part 1 — Cash method (what reached you, what you paid)

Under the cash method, income counts when it is actually or constructively received — "constructively" means it was credited to you or made available without restriction, even if you didn't pick it up. The $2,000 check was in her hands on December 29, so it's 2025 income even though the deposit waited. The other $10,000 arrives in January, so it's 2026 income. Expenses generally count when paid, so the $3,000 cleaning bill is a 2026 deduction. Cash net for 2025: $2,000.

Part 1b — Accrual method (rights and obligations)

Under accrual, income counts when the all-events test is met (right to it is fixed and the amount can be figured reasonably) — for services, generally as you perform them, so the whole $12,000 is 2025 income. An expense counts when the all-events test is met and economic performance has occurred; for services provided to you, economic performance occurs as the service is provided. The cleaning happened in December, so the $3,000 is a 2025 deduction even though it's paid in January. Accrual net: $9,000.

Who may use cash? Most individuals and small businesses can. C corporations, partnerships that have a C corporation as a partner, and tax shelters cannot — unless they meet the gross-receipts test: average annual gross receipts for the prior three years of $31 million or less for 2025 (Rev. Proc. 2024-40; the amount is indexed). Qualified personal service corporations are also excepted. A business that fails the test must switch to accrual starting in the year it fails, using Form 3115.

Part 2 — Changing methods: Form 3115 and the §481(a) adjustment

Suppose Nadia's corporation, Pinecrest Supply, Inc., has average receipts of $33 million and is now over the line, so it must move from cash to accrual on Form 3115. On the day of the switch it has $90,000 of receivables never reported as income (cash method) and $10,000 of payables never deducted. Switching would either double-count or skip those items, so a §481(a) adjustment fixes it: $90,000 − $10,000 = $80,000 positive (it raises income).

Timing: a positive adjustment is generally spread over four tax years (the year of the change and the next three): $80,000 ÷ 4 = $20,000 per year. A negative adjustment (it lowers income) is taken all in the year of change. Form 3115 instructions also describe some short-spread elections for small positive adjustments; don't worry about those unless a question gives them.

Positive = pay more, slowly. Negative = deduct it now. The exam loves asking which way the spread goes, and whether the adjustment starts in the year of change (it does).

Part 3 — Counting the shelves (COGS, FIFO, LIFO)

Cost of goods sold = beginning inventory + purchases − ending inventory. Nadia's goods available for sale are $80,000 + $200,000 = $280,000. The only thing we can change is how we price the 200 units left on the shelf.

FIFO (first-in, first-out) assumes the oldest goods sold first, so what's left is the newest (most expensive) stuff: 200 × $320 = $64,000 of ending inventory, making COGS $216,000. LIFO assumes the newest goods sold first, so what's left is the oldest (cheapest) stuff: 200 × $250 = $50,000, making COGS $230,000. When prices rise, LIFO gives $14,000 more COGS and less taxable income. (This lesson's simple picture puts all 200 leftover units at the newest or oldest unit cost. Real layers can be more complicated.)

Three reminders. (1) Adopting LIFO means filing Form 970 (or a statement with the same information) with the return for the first year you use it. (2) Changing an inventory method is an accounting-method change, so Form 3115 again. (3) A small business taxpayer (average gross receipts of $31 million or less for 2025 and not a tax shelter) can skip formal inventories and instead treat them as non-incidental materials and supplies, or follow its financial statements.

Open the widget

Nadia's December timing: cash vs accrual side by side.

Open D2.methods-books.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
ar12000
ap3000
cr2000

What you should see: Cash net $2,000; accrual net $9,000. The chart shows the same facts landing in different years.

The method change: Pinecrest, Inc. at $33 million of average receipts.

Open D2.methods-books.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
missed90000
missedExp10000
gr33000000

What you should see: §481(a) sketch $80,000 (positive, so generally $20,000 a year for four years) and the receipts test reads 'Over threshold'. Drop receipts to 28,000,000 and it flips to OK.

FIFO cost of goods sold for the shelves.

Open D2.income-cogs.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
bi80000
purch200000
eiUnits200
early250
late320
methodFIFO
gr25000000

What you should see: COGS $216,000.

Same shelves, LIFO. Compare the 'difference' line.

Open D2.income-cogs.html with this scenario filled in →

FieldValue
bi80000
purch200000
eiUnits200
early250
late320
methodLIFO
gr25000000

What you should see: COGS $230,000 — $14,000 higher than FIFO, so lower taxable income.

Practice questions

Answer all of them on paper first. Then tap Show answer & why: the rule, how to decide, why each choice is right or wrong, the numbers, and the IRS source. Want more? The practice set (20 questions) has more scenarios on this topic.

Q1. Nadia finished $12,000 of installs in December. She received a $2,000 check on Dec 29 (undeposited) and the other $10,000 on Jan 10. A cleaning service worked in December and billed $3,000, paid Jan 15. What is the net effect on her 2025 income under the cash method and under the accrual method?

  1. Cash $0; accrual $9,000
  2. Cash $9,000; accrual $2,000
  3. Cash $2,000; accrual $9,000
  4. Both $9,000
Show answer & why

Answer: C — Cash $2,000; accrual $9,000

The rule, in plain English

Cash method: income when actually or constructively received, expenses when paid. Accrual: income when earned, expenses when incurred (economic performance).

How to decide

  1. Cash: which money was received or available by Dec 31? Which bills were paid?
  2. Accrual: what was earned and what services were performed in the year?

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Forgets constructive receipt. Having the check in hand in December counts even if it wasn't deposited.
  • B — Wrong. Reverses the methods.
  • C — Correct. Cash: the check was constructively received ($2,000) and the bill wasn't paid. Accrual: all $12,000 income less the $3,000 service performed in December.
  • D — Wrong. Cash doesn't deduct an unpaid bill or include income not received. Only accrual gets to $9,000.

IRS source

Pub 538, Cash Method / Accrual Method / Constructive receipt.

Q2. Which of the following cannot use the cash method of accounting for 2025 (assume no other exceptions apply)?

  1. A C corporation with average annual gross receipts of $28 million
  2. A C corporation with average annual gross receipts of $33 million for the prior three years
  3. A qualified personal service corporation
  4. A sole proprietor with no inventory who is not a tax shelter
Show answer & why

Answer: B — A C corporation with average annual gross receipts of $33 million for the prior three years

The rule, in plain English

A C corporation can't use the cash method unless it meets the gross-receipts test ($31 million for 2025).

How to decide

  1. Is it a C corporation (not a qualified personal service corporation)?
  2. Average gross receipts for the prior 3 years over $31 million? Then no cash method.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. Under $31 million, so it passes the test and may use cash (if it isn't a tax shelter).
  • B — Correct. C corporations are excluded from cash unless they pass the gross-receipts test, which for 2025 is $31 million.
  • C — Wrong. PSCs are a statutory exception to the cash-method limit.
  • D — Wrong. Sole proprietors aren't among the excluded entities; most use cash.

IRS source

Pub 538; Rev. Proc. 2024-40 §3.31.

Q3. Pinecrest, Inc. changes from cash to accrual on Form 3115. It has $90,000 of receivables never reported and $10,000 of unpaid expenses never deducted. What is the §481(a) adjustment and how is it generally taken?

  1. $80,000 positive; $20,000 a year over four years, starting with the year of change
  2. $90,000 positive; $22,500 a year over four years
  3. $80,000 positive, all in the year of change
  4. $80,000 positive; $20,000 a year for the four years after the year of change
Show answer & why

Answer: A — $80,000 positive; $20,000 a year over four years, starting with the year of change

The rule, in plain English

§481(a) adjustment for cash → accrual = items never reported (receivables − payables). Positive adjustments are generally spread over 4 years starting with the year of change.

How to decide

  1. Receivables not yet reported − expenses not yet deducted.
  2. Positive → 4 years beginning with the year of change; negative → all in the year of change.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Correct. Receivables − payables = $80,000 positive. Positive adjustments are generally spread over four years beginning in the year of change.
  • B — Wrong. Ignores the $10,000 of payables, which offset the adjustment.
  • C — Wrong. That is how a negative adjustment is treated. Positive adjustments are generally spread.
  • D — Wrong. The spread starts in the year of change, not the year after.

IRS source

Form 3115 instructions (§481(a) adjustment periods).

Q4. Beginning inventory is $80,000, purchases are $200,000, and ending inventory is 200 units. The newest units cost $320 and the oldest cost $250. Using FIFO, what is cost of goods sold?

  1. $230,000
  2. $136,000
  3. $280,000
  4. $216,000
Show answer & why

Answer: D — $216,000

The rule, in plain English

FIFO: the oldest costs go to COGS, so ending inventory is priced at the newest costs.

How to decide

  1. Goods available = beginning inventory + purchases.
  2. Ending inventory at the newest costs.
  3. COGS = available − ending inventory.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. That's the LIFO answer (ending inventory priced at the older $250).
  • B — Wrong. Forgets beginning inventory. COGS starts from goods available: beginning + purchases.
  • C — Wrong. Forgets to subtract ending inventory.
  • D — Correct. Goods available $280,000 − FIFO ending inventory (200 × $320 = $64,000) = $216,000.

IRS source

Pub 538, Inventories (FIFO).

Q5. Prices have been rising all year. Compared with FIFO, what does electing LIFO do for this business (same units, same costs as above)?

  1. Lowers COGS by $14,000 and raises taxable income
  2. Raises COGS by $14,000 and lowers taxable income by the same amount
  3. Makes no difference if the same units are sold
  4. Raises ending inventory value and lowers COGS
Show answer & why

Answer: B — Raises COGS by $14,000 and lowers taxable income by the same amount

The rule, in plain English

With rising prices, LIFO prices ending inventory at the oldest (cheapest) costs, raising COGS and lowering taxable income. Adopt it on Form 970.

How to decide

  1. Ending inventory under LIFO at the oldest costs.
  2. Compare COGS with FIFO; the difference is the income change.

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A — Wrong. That's the FIFO direction. LIFO leaves older, cheaper costs in ending inventory.
  • B — Correct. LIFO leaves the cheapest layers in ending inventory, so more of the expensive recent purchases flow to COGS. It needs Form 970 when adopted.
  • C — Wrong. Units are the same, but the cost assigned to ending inventory differs, so COGS differs.
  • D — Wrong. Reversed: LIFO lowers ending inventory value and raises COGS when prices rise.

IRS source

Pub 538, LIFO; Form 970.

Practice set (20 questions)

Same topic, more scenarios: 20 exam-style questions (13 with dollar amounts to work out step by step), each with the rule, how to decide, why every choice is right or wrong, and the IRS source.

Open the practice set (20 questions) →

Close the loop

Key rules in one line

cash = received/paid (constructive receipt); accrual = all-events + economic performance; +481(a) → 4 yrs, −481(a) → 1 yr; COGS = BI + purchases − EI

Memory trigger: Cash counts money you could grab; accrual counts rights and promises; LIFO leaves old cheap stuff on the shelf so COGS goes up when prices rise.

Missed one? Jot down why in My mistake notes — it helps you spot patterns.

Sources checked
  • Pub 538 (Rev. 1-2022): cash and accrual methods, constructive receipt, economic performance, excluded entities and gross-receipts test, inventories, FIFO/LIFO, Form 970, small business exception. (This edition still shows the older $26 million figure.)
  • Rev. Proc. 2024-40 §3.31: for 2025 the §448(c) gross-receipts threshold is $31,000,000 (Rev. Proc. 2025-32 shows $32,000,000 for 2026).
  • Instructions for Form 3115 (12/2022): §481(a) adjustment periods (one year for negative, four years for positive). Not re-verified against a 2025 edition.
  • UNICAP (§263A) small-business exemption uses the same gross-receipts test per the statute; not separately verified in a downloaded IRS publication.

Study material, not tax advice or an IRS publication. Numbers follow tax year 2025 (the Nov 2026 SEE tests 2025 law per the Candidate Information Bulletin).